Credit: MLB.Com
BOSTON, MA — Instant Reaction to the Yankees 6-4 loss to the Red Sox on Sunday Night Baseball, falling to 83-66 on the season.
The Yankees went down 1-2-3 in the first inning, including strikeouts from Slater and Judge.
Will Warren was awful today. He allowed five strict hits to start the game, and then got two outs, both scoring runs, before allowing a home run to Narvarez. He put the Yankees in an immediate 6-0 hole. To me, this game should have eliminated him from the conversation of getting a postseason starts, given his regular blowups against postseason teams.
The Yankees first hit of the game off Crochet was a Ben Rice double in the gap. He was stranded at second base after back-to-back strikeouts of Slater and Judge. Crochet racked up seven strikeouts through the first three innings.
After a Stanton single in the fourth inning, Amed Rosario crust a 2-run home run off Crochet, who he is 6-8 against this season to get the Yankees on the board. This one just cleared the Monster in Left.
Amed Rosario hits his first #Yankees home run over the Monstah.
6-2 NYY
— #Matthew Nethercott (#@mnethercott_)
12:18 AM • Sep 15, 2025
Aaron Judge did not strike out in his third at-bat against Crochet. He took a fastball deep into the Boston bullpen to make this a 6-3 ballgame. It was Judge’s 48th home run of the season.
Judge takes Crochet Deep at Fenway again. Deep into the Boston Bullpen
6-3 BOS
— #Matthew Nethercott (#@mnethercott_)
12:35 AM • Sep 15, 2025
Warren was back out or the fifth inning and though there was a lot of traffic, he held the Red Sox scoreless. Warren really gave the Yankees offense a chance to get right back in this game.
Warren’s Final Line: 5 IP | 10 H | 6 ER | 1 BB | 2 K | 1 HR | 89-59 P/S | 4.44 ERA
Warren was very shakey early, but from the second inning through the fifth inning Warren looked a lot better. Warren’s ERA this season is 9.20 in three games against Boston.
Jose Caballero would get another run back to get the Yankees a run closer, sending a ball to Lansdowne street. Caballero recorded an extra base hit in each game at Fenway this weekend and is making the bid go get some more reps at shortstop.
Caballero puts one over the Monster on to Lansdowne Street.
6-4 BOS
— #Matthew Nethercott (#@mnethercott_)
1:10 AM • Sep 15, 2025
The Yankees brought the tying run to the plate three times in the eighth inning after Judge lead off with a single. Bellinger, Stanton, and Grisham all struck out, Bellinger and Judge looking, and that killed the momentum the Yankees were gaining.
The Yankees bullpen — Doval, Leiter and Blackburn — held the Red Sox scoreless there three innings, on just two hits. And Caballero made a really nice play to end the eighth and save a run.
INSANE play by Caballero to save a run 😳
— #The Yankee Report (#@YankeeReport_)
1:41 AM • Sep 15, 2025
The Yankees would face Aroldis Chapman in the ninth inning, and they were sent down in order to drop the finally to Boston.