NEW YORK — Anthony Volpe has been the subject of growing debate among Yankees fans, as questions regarding his role and future with the team continue to intensify — regardless of whether the organization publicly acknowledges the concern.

Through the 2025 season, Volpe has struggled to meet expectations, particularly in the areas that were once considered his strengths. While his “defense-first” reputation was a major point of optimism heading into the year, his defensive performance has notably regressed.

Offensively, Volpe has shown significant difficulties at the plate. His approach has been widely criticized for lacking discipline and competitiveness, often resulting in poor at-bats. In high-leverage situations, opposing pitchers have demonstrated a willingness to pitch around other hitters to face Volpe, indicating a lack of fear in his offensive capabilities. As of midseason, Volpe leads Major League Baseball in runners left on base with 160, yet has recorded only 49 runs batted in. Although no player is expected to drive in every baserunner, the disparity between his RBI total and the number of runners stranded reflects an ongoing concern with his situational hitting.

Anthony Volpe’s defensive performance has notably declined this season, raising concerns about his reliability in critical situations. His inconsistency in the field has resulted in numerous runs and bases allowed, contributing to the Yankees’ defensive struggles.

Given the team’s stated emphasis on strong defense throughout the season, Volpe’s regression has been particularly significant. When asked about Volpe’s performance, manager Aaron Boone has remained fiercely supportive, even stating that Volpe is “fucking elite,” reflecting the organization’s continued belief in his long-term potential despite recent shortcomings.

The central issue is that Anthony Volpe needs to deliver a strong second half of the season. Following this year, Volpe will become arbitration eligible, meaning the Yankees and his representatives must negotiate a new salary for the 2026 season. The Yankees have historically taken a hardline stance during arbitration, often leveraging performance shortcomings to minimize salary increases. This approach can strain the relationship between player and organization and, depending on how the process unfolds, could lead to a contentious outcome between Volpe and the club.

(Top Image Credit: Brian Fluharty, USA TODAY Sports)